How Did Louisville Get So Bad?


There is lots of finger-pointing connected with this University of Louisville basketball team. Most comments are not complimentary. But to place all the blame on Kenny Payne is unfair. The things that have happened to this athletic department since 2016 are unprecedented. All the turmoil hurt the men’s basketball program more than most fans realize. UofL decided to take the Kenny Payne route out of purgatory. Former AD Tom Jurich did good things, as did former Coach Rick Pitino. But the end results are some of the reasons this team is limping toward a record-setting losing season. One could go on and on about the many missteps in the last several years. But that is in the past.

Louisville officially names Kenny Payne new head men's basketball coach - Card Chronicle

Photo Cred: Card Chronicle

Louisville’s Biggest issue is everything. The first year of the Kenny Payne era has been rough. Turnovers and defensive breakdowns are noticeable. After starting the season with three consecutive one-point losses, Louisville has been blown out game after game. The Cardinals lost their ACC-Big Ten Challenge game against No. 22 Maryland 79-54. Louisville has no flow to offense.

Louisville vs Notre Dame: Emmanuel Okorafor has solid debut for Cards

Photo Cred: Courier Journal

Louisville doesn’t have many answers part due to its roster construction. Some of this is due to the punishment Louisville was to receive this year. It scared players away, but the result of the NCAA investigation was a mild reprimand. Some key players that were on last year’s basketball team are playing elsewhere, including Samuel Williamson (at Southern Methodist) and Dre Davis (at Seton Hall).

Kenny Payne era at Louisville starts with 57-47 exhibition loss to Lenoir-Rhyne - Card Chronicle

Photo Cred: Card Chronicle

When Coach Chris Mack left, I blamed some of that on former President Neeli Bendapudi. She wanted Mack dismissed immediately after allegations from his top assistant but then Athletics Director Vince Tyra stood his ground. After playing shooting guard almost exclusively last season, El Ellis is playing point guard this season, and his turnover rate is the highest among 41 players who have had at least 150 possessions this season, according to Synergy Sports.

App State hands Louisville third straight one-point loss

Photo Cred: Spectrum News

Louisville compounds its turnover troubles with woeful transition defense. The Cardinals have allowed 20 points per game off turnovers ranking in the bottom half of college basketball. Louisville thought they would improve in some areas with Ellis getting more comfortable at point guard. But that has not happened. Fixing the effort and communication, though, maybe a tough task. Louisville has not even appeared in the NCAA tournament since 2019. If the Cardinals miss out again  and it certainly doesn’t look good now  that would be three dance  Marches in a row. That hasn’t happened at Louisville since 1971.


  1. All of this is true, but even talking about missing the NCAA tournament deflects the true reality of where the Louisville program is right now. Their final NET ranking was 315 and KenPom puts them slightly better, not quite 300. But this is not a point from which we should be thinking about the NCAA tournament while playing in the ACC. I think it would be best for all around if Louisville and the ACC parted ways.

    I think the Ohio Valley Conference would be a great fit for us right now. Some natural geographic rivals like Morehead State and a setting where Louisville could be competitive within a couple of years if they make smart recruiting decisions, now that Belmont and Murray State have moved on. I now this wouldn’t be popular with everyone, but even with the ACC’s decline (Duke being the only legitimate top 25 team this year) we are talking about a decade rebuild to get back to where we were in the Pervis Ellison days. Better to spend that decade in a league where we can be competitive and after that, we can move back up when we are ready.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.